How Best Beer Rates Beer Styles
At Best Beer, we understand that beer is as diverse as it is delightful, with a multitude of styles that offer something unique to every palate. Our goal is to guide you through this rich landscape, helping you discover the best beer that suits your taste. To achieve this, we’ve developed a comprehensive and meticulous rating system that evaluates beer styles on several key factors, ensuring that our recommendations reflect the very best the world of brewing has to offer.
The Rating Process
Our beer rating process is rooted in a deep appreciation for the craft, combining objective analysis with the refined palate of our editor, Mary J. Hicks. Here’s how we rate the beer styles that make it onto our lists:
1. Flavor Profile
The flavor of a beer is its most defining characteristic. We evaluate the balance, complexity, and harmony of flavors in each beer style, whether it’s the rich maltiness of a stout, the hoppy bitterness of an IPA, or the crisp refreshment of a pilsner. Our ratings reflect the depth and nuance of the flavors that each style offers, highlighting the beers that deliver exceptional taste experiences.
2. Aroma
A beer’s aroma is the first impression it makes, and it’s an integral part of the tasting experience. We assess the aroma for its intensity, quality, and how well it complements the beer’s flavor. From the floral notes of a pale ale to the roasted scent of a porter, the aroma plays a crucial role in our evaluation.
3. Appearance
The visual appeal of a beer is more than just aesthetics—it provides clues about the brewing process and the style’s characteristics. We consider the clarity, color, and head retention of the beer, ensuring that it meets the traditional standards of its style while also appealing to the eye.
4. Mouthfeel
Mouthfeel refers to the texture and body of the beer, which can range from light and effervescent to full and creamy. Our ratings take into account how well the mouthfeel matches the style’s expectations and how it contributes to the overall drinking experience.
5. Authenticity
Authenticity is about staying true to the traditional characteristics of a beer style while allowing room for creativity and innovation. We rate beers based on how faithfully they represent their style, whether it’s a classic Belgian ale or a modern American craft beer. Authenticity ensures that the beer remains recognizable and respected within its category.
6. Overall Impression
Finally, we consider the overall impression of the beer. This holistic view takes into account the beer’s drinkability, how well the various elements work together, and the lasting impact it leaves on the palate. The best beers are those that not only excel in individual aspects but also create a memorable and enjoyable experience as a whole.